FAIREST & BEST
MEN’S A RESERVE
| 1972 | N. Peating | Collegians |
| 1973 | R. Richmond | CBC |
| 1974 | N. Cassidy | CBC |
| 1975 | K. Sleigh | University |
| 1975 | N. Watson | Carlisle |
| Grade Reintroduced 1997 | ||
| 1997 | G. Robson | University |
| 1997 | S. Curran | West Coast |
| 1998 | G. Jones | Scarborough |
| 1999 | G. Jones | Scarborough |
| 2000 | G. Jones | Scarborough |
| 2001 | C. Longmore | CBC |
| 2002 | B. Cox | North Fremantle |
| 2003 | J. Abbott | CBC |
| 2003 | S. Campbell | Swan Athletic |
| 2004 | J. Abbott | CBC |
| 2005 | D. Peake | Scarborough |
| 2006 | S. MacNamara | Collegians |
| 2007 | L. Howard | Trinity Aquinas |
| 2008 | G. Austen | Wesley Curtin |
| 2009 | L. Howard | Trinity Aquinas |
| 2010 | J. Jones | North Fremantle |
| 2011 | A. Northover | Trinity Aquinas |
| 2012 | S. Pearce | North Beach |
| 2013 | W. Hughes | Swan Athletic |
| 2014 | B. Hinkley | Swan Athletic |
| 2015 | K. Williams | Wesley Curtin |
| 2016 | K. Williams | Wesley Curtin |
| 2017 | A. O'Brien | Wembley |
| 2018 | K. Williams | Curtin University Wesley |
| 2019 | N. Bowe | North Beach |
| 2020 | T. Bowering | University |
| 2020 | M. Kirk | University |
| 2021 | J. Chapman | North Beach |
| 2022 | T. Zeeman | Scarborough |
| 2023 | D. Keighran | Mount Lawley |
| 2024 | D. Rudd | Fremantle CBC |
| 2025 | B. Ebsworth | Scarborough |