FAIREST & BEST
MEN’S A GRADE
Isaachsen Medal 1924
Sampson Medal 1931
Caris Trophy 1932
R.B. Henkel Trophy 1933
C.J. Jamieson Medal 1990-current
| 1931 | A. MacPherson (Hurlingham) | 1961 | A. Hughes (South Perth) | 1991 | W. Dawson (Scarborough) |
| 1932 | A. Fisher (University) | 1961 | M. Ninyette (East Perth) | 1992 | M. Cartier (Mt Lawley) |
| 1933 | R. Roe (University) | 1962 | B. Lambert (Cockburn) | 1993 | J. Cook (Mt Lawley) |
| 1934 | R. Roe (University) | 1963 | B. Lambert (North Fremantle) | 1994 | T. Wislon (Nollamara) |
| 1935 | A. Reardon (Postal Institute) | 1964 | N. Rotham (Wembley) | 1995 | A. Fullgrabe (Scarborough) |
| 1936 | S. Miller (Sandovers) | 1965 | R. Harding (Vic Park) | 1996 | T. Coaker (North Beach) |
| 1937 | D. Ryan (Water Supply) | 1966 | B. Lambert (North Fremantle) | 1997 | P. Brooks (C.B.C) |
| 1938 | J. Bowe (Wembley) | 1967 | T. Rieusett (Carlisle) | 1998 | P. Brooks (C.B.C) |
| 1939 | K. Swain (Claremont) | 1968 | J. Hurren (Carlisle) | 1999 | C. Trew (North Beach) |
| 1940 | R. Hagen (Inglewood) | 1969 | R. Dook (Wembley) | 2000 | R. Thomson (Scarborough) |
| 1941 | A. Shields (R.A.A.F) | 1970 | G. Watt (Carlisle) | 2001 | S. Freeman (North Fremantle) |
| 1942–45 | No Competition | 1970 | A. Barnett (University) | 2002 | T. McNeill (North Beach) |
| 1946 | D. Lind (R.A.A.F) | 1971 | A. Barnett (University) | 2003 | S. Hede (Collegians) |
| 1947 | W. Anderson (University) | 1972 | R. Becker (Mosman Park) | 2004 | T. Feist (Whitford) |
| 1948 | V. Lemon (Mt Hawthorn) | 1973 | A. Bovell (University) | 2004 | W. Otway (Whitford) |
| 1949 | D. Elliott (South Perth) | 1974 | G. Neesham (C.B.C) | 2005 | D. Macdonald(Whitford) |
| 1950 | A. Parentich (University) | 1975 | J. Riseley (Carlisle) | 2006 | K. Loxley (University) |
| 1951 | A. Loo (East Perth) | 1976 | L. Giamuzina (Leederville) | 2007 | A. Piccoli (Wembley) |
| 1952 | L. Beard (Mosman Park) | 1977 | G. Hambley (North Beach) | 2008 | B. Goodall (Wesley Curtin) |
| 1953 | R. O'Connor (Maylands) | 1978 | G. Hambley (North Beach) | 2009 | M. Atkins (Wesley Curtin) |
| 1954 | J. Hilton (Inglewood) | 1979 | D. Ireland (Mt Lawley) | 2010 | M. Cooper (Wesley Curtin) |
| 1955 | J. Kenshaw (Mosman Park) | 1980 | D. Taylor (Wembley) | 2011 | C. Gribble (Mt Lawley) |
| 1956 | J. Hilton (Inglewood) | 1981 | N. Fong (Nollamara) | 2012 | R. D'Alton (North Fremantle) |
| 1957 | R. Thomas (Mosman Park) | 1982 | N. Fong (Nollamara) | 2013 | P. O'Keefe (Trinity Aquinas) |
| 1958 | R. Thomas (Mosman Park) | 1983 | N. Fong (Nollamara) | 2014 | B. Chen (Fremantle CBC) |
| 1959 | W. James (North Fremantle) | 1984 | L. Sprlyan (North Beach) | 2015 | B. Nisbett (West Coast) |
| 1960 | A. Hughes (South Perth) | 1985 | J. Bengough (Scarborough) | 2016 | C. Basile (Fremantle CB) |
| 1961 | A. Hughes (South Perth) | 1986 | G. Dennis (North Beach) | 2017 | C. Basile (Fremantle CBC) |
| 1961 | M. Ninyette (East Perth) | 1987 | D. Perry (North Beach) | 2017 | H. Murray (University) |
| 1969 | R. Dook (Wembley) | 1995 | A. Fullgrabe (Scarborough) | 2025 | C. Leonard (Curtin Uni Wesley) |
| 1970 | G. Watt (Carlisle) | 1996 | T. Coaker (North Beach) | ||
| 1970 | A. Barnett (University) | 1997 | P. Brooks (C.B.C) | ||
| 1971 | A. Barnett (University) | 1998 | P. Brooks (C.B.C) | ||
| 1972 | R. Becker (Mosman Park) | 1999 | C. Trew (North Beach) | ||
| 1973 | A. Bovell (University) | 2000 | R. Thomson (Scarborough) | ||
| 1974 | G. Neesham (C.B.C) | 2001 | S. Freeman (North Fremantle) | ||
| 1975 | J. Riseley (Carlisle) | 2002 | T. McNeill (North Beach) | ||
| 1976 | L. Giamuzina (Leederville) | 2003 | S. Hede (Collegians) |